Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • RSS Feed


  • Tax Hike Wall of Shame























    Boiling Frogs Slowly: Rep. Chris Ward Explains His Vote in Free Press Op-ed


    By chetly, Section News
    Posted on Sun Oct 07, 2007 at 06:52:29 PM EST

    Cross-posted at OaklandPolitics.com.

    State Rep. Chris Ward (R-Brighton, parts of Oakland County) explained his vote for taxes today in the Detroit Free Press.  I take the liberty of posting the whole thing, since its written by a legislator, below the fold. 

    I like Chris Ward.  He's a nice guy.  He supported Proposal 2.  Most of his work has been good.  He's a fun guy to have a beer with.  But politics isn't usually "personal" - and even "recalls" aren't personal.  His notion that "term-limits" made the legislators interaction "like having to get engaged on a first date" is simply passing the buck and trying to take advantage of a bad situation to encourage longer-term limits.  It's cliche, passe, and wrong.  He's simply wrong to even bring it up as an excuse - even if term-limits should be reformed, the (created)  "crisis" is being used an irrelevant political weapon to "reform" them.  So his very mention of term-limits here is disappointing -- I have no problem with him lobbying for longer-limits (though I disagree), but I have a problem with him using a crisis' he is largely responsible for to justify them.

    Second, I have no problem with compromise generally.  Compromise can be good, and it can be bad.  Was there even a "compromise" here.  The Governor demanded a budget with a 4.6% income tax and no more than $300-400 million in spending reforms.  She wouldn't budge.  Bishop even offered to meet her 56% of the way 4.3%.  She told him to take a hike.  She created a crisis, held legislators in a confined room, and waited for a blink.  That's not compromise.  We ended up with a 4.35% income tax and the remaining 0.25% equivalent hidden in a sales tax expansion, with spending cuts not exceeding -- you guessed it, $400 million (not even agreed to yet, actually, only in principle).  Ward may have felt there was a gun to his - or the State's - head, and a vote in that situation may be justified.  But it wasn't compromise. 

    Finally, has this solved anything "long-term," as Chris suggests?  If it had solved our long-term structural crisis, I'd be more inclined to see Chris's point.  But even the left admits it hasn't, and that more tax increases are to come.  That's the nature of tax increases - they come incrementally.  They boil the frogs slowly.

    The Detroit Free Press link:

    Compromise avoided state crisis

    October 7, 2007

    BY STATE REP. CHRIS WARD

      Compromise has become an ugly word in today's political arena.

    In this era of the permanent campaign and instant punditry, there is little benefit for politicians to find common ground. Perhaps former U.S. Sen. Jesse Helms was right when he said that the middle of the road was the surest place to get run over.It took a government shutdown for a bare majority of Michigan legislators to exercise their constitutional duty to pass a balanced budget. A lot has been made on both sides of the debate about courage and backbone on the part of legislators, regardless of how they voted. To me, the remarkable aspect of this debacle is that the state had to be on the brink of a constitutional crisis for us to do the jobs we were elected to do.

    I abhor taxes. My voting record in the nearly five years I have served in the Michigan House has been quite clear on that point. For many of my Democratic colleagues to vote against their union friends is equally abhorrent. Yet the people of the state elected both of us to serve them.

    As an elected official, the temptation was strong to keep my head low and hope someone else would clean up this mess. The safest thing to do in politics most of the time is to vote no and point at shortcomings of whatever proposal is before you. As a member of the minority party, this would have been an acceptable approach in many people's minds.

    The truth is this crisis provided a rare opportunity to fix some of Michigan's long-term problems. The skyrocketing costs of public employee pensions and health care have long been breaking the bank of our public schools. Yet what has been more than clear after years of trying, Republicans alone could not muster the support to make necessary reforms happen.

    The resulting compromise fell far short of what I wanted. I remain deeply opposed to the sales tax component of the deal and will do everything in my power to see that portion of it repealed. Frankly, if work had started well before the shutdown was imminent, I believe the result would have been much better. There is plenty of blame to go around. In this era of term limits, Lansing leaders were expected to accomplish the equivalent of getting engaged on their first date.

    There is quite a bit of talk about recall against me and some other legislators because of our votes. If that is the price I have to pay for doing what was right in a crisis situation, then so be it. There are a lot more important things in life than being a state representative. I only caution voters to be apprehensive of full-time, paid political operators who care more about their career success than finding solutions for a troubled state.

      CHRIS WARD, R-Brighton, represents the 66th state House District. Contact him at either chrisward@house.mi.gov or 517-373-1784

     
    < McCain Launches Michigan Web Ad with Utah Governor Jon Huntsman | It's time for a change. >
    Display: Sort:
    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Join the RightMichigan.com Facebook Group HERE!
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!
    create account | faq | search