Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • RSS Feed


  • Tax Hike Wall of Shame


















    House Republicans strike a blow for fiscal sanity


    By Nick, Section News
    Posted on Thu Nov 01, 2007 at 07:54:37 AM EST

    Bookmark this article.  Then, the next time you're sitting around wondering if Lansing is paying attention to the activists (and the blogosphere) go to your favorites and come back to re-read it.  

    After much discussion in recent weeks about dissatisfaction with tax hike votes followed by yes votes on appropriations bills that actually spend the new tax dollars, the House Republican Caucus went on the offensive yesterday introducing a package of spending cuts that meets and exceeds the amount of money swiped from working moms and dads by Andy Dillon via a sales tax on services.  

    That tax is projected to collect over $613 million.  The House GOP has identified $677 million in immediate cuts and reforms and proposed them along with a complete repeal of the new Democrat tax.  

    Read on...

    Now the idea of repealing the tax isn't new.  Business groups began mobilizing the moment it was passed in the early morning hours one month ago to the day.  But the focus thus far, while Granholm and Dillon control the discussion, has been on finding a preferred alternative.  They've discussed another income tax jump, they've discussed a progressive income tax on the ballot, they've discussed a general hike to the Michigan Business Tax... but every discussion has involved replacement revenue, a reflection of how devastating the House Democrat tax hike really was.  

    In effect you've got business agreeing "if you're going to shoot me will you at least shoot me in the foot instead of the head so I've got a fighting chance to survive?"

    Today's DetNews reports:

    "I am and have been in discussion with the business community about what that (change) could look like. My criteria for the replacement are that it is revenue-neutral, and bipartisan and it's not temporary, (said Granholm)."

    Oakland County Executive L. Brooks Patterson is to kick off a petition drive today to repeal the levy, which expands the 6 percent sales tax on goods to a mix of services starting Dec. 1.  Patterson represents the business Coalition to Ax the Tax.

    "She's wrong on all three points," Patterson said. "We should repeal it and not replace it with any new tax on business, because you can't tax your way to prosperity."

    After hearing from pro-job, pro-growth advocates like Patterson and the `sphere for weeks the House GOP is beginning to respond, hoping to ignite a rebellion in the Chamber.  Craig DeRoche and the House GOP yesterday unveiled a plan that takes the gun out of the Democrats' hands completely.  

    It doesn't just repeal the tax, it backs it up with real, substantive spending cuts and reforms.  Props to the caucus for not giving up the fight and for taking a stand.  The idea that we could face a fiscal crisis and emerge from it with $1.4 BILLION in new taxes and a BIGGER overall and BIGGER General Purpose / General Fund expense sheet than even last year is simply unacceptable.  And it looks like the House Republicans agree.  

    Their list of proposed cuts includes:

    1.    Five percent legislator pay cut - $600,000

    2.    Michigan Business tax transition windfall - $219,400,000

    3.    Reexamine state employee benefits - $100,000,000

    4.    Department of Information Technology Reduction - $10,000,000

    5.    Competitively bid corrections services - $50,000,000    

    6.    Eliminate tax exemption benefiting prisoners - $3,000,000

    7.    Streamline the Department of Community Health - $92,833,331


  • Reduction to Healthy Michigan Fund programming

  • Restructure Wayne County Community Mental Health

  • Reform 19-and 20-year olds non-mandatory coverage

  • Reform non-mandatory Medicaid caretaker coverage

  • Invest more money into Medicaid fraud investigations

    Department of Human Services reforms - $109,499,998


  • Four year limit for able bodied welfare recipients

  • Privatize daycare eligibility

  • Daycare rate uniformity


    8.    Stop news appropriation to 21st Century Jobs program - $75,000,000

    9.    Eliminate the Community Service Commission Grant to train volunteers - $3,190,000

    10.    Remove the increase to the Treasury Department to implement the new taxes - $8,900,000

    11.    Continued reduction of public transit funding - $5,000,000

    Revenue generated from the Service Tax: $614 million

    GRAND TOTAL in savings from the House Republican plan:  $677 million

    This is anything but a lock.  Dillon and his whips will try to scuttle it and keep it from ever getting out of the gate.  Holding the majority carries a lot of weight.  But it's a big step, a signal, in the right direction.

  • < When are 7,000 layoffs not a bad thing? When you've endorsed Hillary for President! | Thursday in the Sphere, November 1, 2007 >
    Display: Sort:
    Good start, but... (none / 0) (#1)
    by Ed Burley on Thu Nov 01, 2007 at 11:48:59 AM EST
    Many of these things are mere reductions, which means that the GOP still considers them a function of government, and that means that in the future, the price tag can increase again.

    Government in Michigan needs more than just cuts. It needs real reform; a change in the focus of its purpose. That is not to say that these cuts are not a good thing. I, too, believe that a lot of this stuff needs to be accomplished bit by bit, a little at a time. Most folks still are of the mentality that government is supposed to fund education - that's why I think that vouchers and/or tax credits are a viable option. The same with welfare; use tax credits as a way to break the power of the Magistrate.

    So, not to be too contrarian - this is a good development; but we need specifics, and then we need them to start working on fundamental change. In spite of this, thanks for keeping us in the loop, Nick. Your site is a lifeline.

    ed


    reforms and cuts 2 (none / 0) (#2)
    by Eric T on Thu Nov 01, 2007 at 01:34:44 PM EST
    Did you ever wake up and feel you just ain't paying enough in taxes.? I don't think many do. It is time for the state to realize that the democrats are not really for the working class. When they constantly are trying to sell the public a story of how broke the state is, you look into it and find tons of wasteful spending, unnecessary programs. And an arrogance that they are running the state so effiecently that no cuts or reforms are necessary.

    I'll do you one better. (none / 0) (#3)
    by KG One on Thu Nov 01, 2007 at 03:46:08 PM EST
    Mandate that all appropriations specify where they derive their authority at from the Michigan Constitution.

    No authority, no spending.

    Just watch those budget numbers fall like a brick when this is implemented.

    You will also be able to eliminate even more than the service tax (cough cough, income tax, cough cough).

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Join the RightMichigan.com Facebook Group HERE!
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!

    Related Links

    + Today's DetNews
    + Also by Nick
    create account | faq | search