Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • RSS Feed


  • Tax Hike Wall of Shame


















    My Thoughts on the Current Tax Crisis


    By Jack Brandenburg, Section News
    Posted on Fri Nov 30, 2007 at 01:29:50 PM EST

    Greetings to everyone here at Right Michigan.  In light of the House Democrats' decision earlier this week to adjourn without addressing an onerous, job-killing tax hike scheduled to go into effect tomorrow at 12:01 AM I think it's important to look back at where we've been and examine once again where it is we should be going.  

    Our state constitution mandates that on October 1st of every year, Michigan's budget has to be balanced.  This year there was a 1.8 billion dollar deficit in the budget for fiscal years 07/08.  The Governor stated numerous times in a very public way that she wanted to cover this deficit with a 1.5 billion dollar tax increase.  For the record, I did not and will not ever support an idea as weak as this.  When deficits occur, slapping a tax on the public is the easiest thing for elected officials to do.  The state of our economy dictates that we move away from the status quo with reforms and a very serious restructuring of our government.  The Governor has been very blunt in her ideas on how to extract billions of dollars from the public.  Her favorite idea was a 2% tax on all services.  Another idea she considered was increasing the state income tax rate from 3.9% to 4.4%, a 15% increase.  She considered charging a 6% sales tax on all entertainment type activity.  And when the dust settled at the end of this budget process she'd succeeded in foisting on Michigan residents a $1.5 billion tax increase with a compliance cost on businesses of nearly a billion additional dollars.

    Read on...

    We've constantly read and heard about this debate in Lansing.  You already know what my position is on this issue.  One thing you won't hear too much about is that the Governor has an additional 1.75 billion dollars worth of spending increases built into and throughout the budget.  If I were the Governor, I would have frozen spending to that of last year's spending levels.  I would then force all department heads to cut their budgets by 3% for fiscal years 07/08.  Everyone, and I mean everyone, can make do with 3% less for a year.

    I will make no bones about this: I am a fiscal conservative, and I always will be.  Being a business owner for the last 27 years has taught me that if I don't have revenue to buy inventory, I won't buy it.  As a taxpayer myself, I am dead tired of all the entities that depend upon tax dollars always crying poverty and wanting more.  My reaction to that is to make do with what you have, because taxpayers are maxed out.  Michigan has been suffering from a structural deficit now for seven years.  A structural deficit is a deficit that will exist in bad or good economic times. (That's scary.)  Therefore, we have to address the structure of the spending and restructure the way Michigan does business, with no exceptions.  If I were the Governor, I would not hesitate for one minute to make the necessary structural changes to put our economy back on the path to prosperity.

    I learned in Economics 101 that you do not extract 1.5 billion dollars via a tax increase, then expect an economy to grow.

    Listed below are what I think are some basic common sense reforms that I want to fight for:

    1.  Michigan ranks 9th in the nation for it's number of state employees (52,000) and ranks 9th in the nation for what they are paid.  Due to the terrible economic times, I would trim this work force by 5%.  Since I have been State Representative, I have never heard of a government employee being laid off.  It happens every day in the private sector.  What's good for the goose, is good for the gander.  The yearly savings would be 450 million dollars.

    2.  Enact meaningful welfare reform for all able-bodied individuals.  Michigan pays 450 dollars per month and has a four year eligibility cap.  Ohio, Illinois, and Indiana all have two and three year caps, and pay roughly 350 dollars per month.  The yearly savings would be 85 million dollars.

    3.  Many of Michigan's school districts have obscene amounts of money in their surplus accounts.  Enact legislation that would prohibit school districts from keeping more than 15% of their operating budgets in surplus. The yearly savings would be 300 million dollars.

    4.  Place 10% of our state's convicts into privately managed prisons.  The RIO GRANDE FOUNDATION report states that we would save 14% in our costs of incarceration.  The yearly savings would be 560 million dollars.

    5.  We must reform Medicaid and provide incentives to people to take better care of themselves.  If we could just realize 3.5 percent inefficiencies from Medicaid, the yearly savings would be 480 million dollars.

    These are just five examples of reforms and restructuring that, if enacted, would create a savings of 1.875 billion dollars, more than enough to offset the original deficit of 1.8 billion dollars and certainly enough to offset a full repeal of the Demorcats' onerous sales tax on services.  

    Remember that deficits do not occur because we are taxing too little, they occur because we are spending too much.  As always, it is my pleasure and my honor to serve the people of the 24th District, and the taxpayers of the State of Michigan.

    Thank you for what you are doing in your communities.  I hope you won't hesitate to leave a comment or to email me at:  jackbrandenburg@house.mi.gov

    < If you put lipstick on a pig, is it still a pig? | It's Christmas time, the TIME for miracles, so be of good cheer! >
    Display: Sort:
    Thanks, Representative (none / 0) (#1)
    by Nick on Fri Nov 30, 2007 at 01:46:00 PM EST
    for taking the time!  And more importantly, for fighting the fight!

    Sir, we all know (none / 0) (#2)
    by PMOTVRWC on Fri Nov 30, 2007 at 02:04:53 PM EST
    how we got where we are and what needs to be done, unfortunately we have a governor who has proven time and again that she is a failure at leadership and hasn't the foggiest idea of how to fix a broken fingernail let alone this states economy.  But, she has the House which is in lockstep with her so no matter what you or any Republican wants to do is at the mercy of card carrying socialists.

    The best solution for fixing this state is a 5% to 10% across the board cut in spending and for the legislature to go parttime.

    I do appreciate however, that you took the time to write to us here at rightmichigan.com, but you're preaching to the choir.    

    • Opps, by PMOTVRWC, 11/30/2007 02:10:50 PM EST (none / 0)
    a little late for the deep thoughts jack... (none / 0) (#4)
    by Rghlive on Sat Dec 01, 2007 at 05:32:40 PM EST
    it's great to see that you have an understanding of what SHOULD have been done but your words -- now that the Michigan house and senate have done more damage to this great State than anyone in our previous history -- ring a bit hollow. I'm starting to think we need to clean house (pun intended) across the board. Remember it took a few of our Republicans to inflict the damage of the new tax plan.

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Join the RightMichigan.com Facebook Group HERE!
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!

    Related Links

    + Also by Jack Brandenburg
    create account | faq | search