Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • RSS Feed


  • Tax Hike Wall of Shame























    Right Michigan Multimedia

    MORE...

    UPDATE: Vulnerable Dems run from iPod, call caucus "misguided" (and other news)


    By Nick, Section News
    Posted on Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 09:53:01 AM EST

    Do you think 2010 Gubernatorial Candidate and current House Speaker Andy Dillon wishes he had a mulligan on this one?  MLIVE's cover story this morning is continuing coverage on the House Dems great budget panacea, free MP3 players in the hands of every school kid in the state.  You get this sort of coverage when you wave around an iPod in front of the press, tell them you want to spend $38 million on technology in the classroom and that you'd like every kid in the state to have one of the fancy toys you're showing them.

    Of course, stupid ideas tend to send your vulnerable caucus member scurrying for cover, too.

    Read on...

    A proposal to buy iPods and MP3 players for K-12 students had some Democratic lawmakers distancing themselves Wednesday from the idea endorsed by others in their party.

    "It's absolutely, utterly ridiculous," said Rep. Mike Simpson, a Democrat from Jackson County's Liberty Township. "We need to be focused on getting our finances in order, not talking about iPods. It's wrong. It's a bad idea. It needs to be shot down and put to bed."

    The idea first surfaced last Thursday, when House Speaker Andy Dillon and other Democrats mentioned during a news conference on the state budget that they wanted to spend $38 million on "21st Century Learning Environments."

    Rep. Matt Gillard, a Democrat from Alpena and chairman of the House subcommittee overseeing K-12 school budgets, said some money should be spent on iPods because they can help students learn.

    "We want this in the hands of every student in the state of Michigan," Gillard said.  (As he held an iPod to show reporters.)

    Word is today there'll be a press conference in Lansing where members of Andy Dillon's causcus will try to answer questions about a proposal that's turned them into a national laughing stock with coverage lampooning them from tech publications to editorial boards to the overseas press and the Drudge Report.  

    UPDATE!  More vulnerable House Dems are running as far away from this one as they can.

    Marc Corriveau states on his own state-operated district website:

    "Although I believe it is essential to upgrade the technology in our schools, now is not the time pitch a program that gives our kids iPods when our state is facing this severe budget crisis," Corriveau said. "I promised the residents of the 20th District that I would be their independent voice. When there is something going on that I do not agree with, I will speak out against it, and that is what I am doing now. This is the wrong thing for Michigan to be spending money on."

    A plan announced last week proposed spending $38 million on technology in schools, including some funding for iPods for students. Corriveau feels that because Michigan is facing an unprecedented budget crisis that remains unresolved, the state should focus on meeting fundamental needs first.

    And Terry Brown is quoted in the Huron Daily Tribune this morning echoing the same sentiment (even using the same verbage... talking points anyone?)

    "I'm in favor of upgrading technology in our schools, but giving kids iPods is a pilot project not worth pursuing at this time," he stated in a press release.

    "When something's right, I'll say so. And when something's wrong, I'll speak up. This is the wrong time for this idea."

    So how do you fix a problem like that?  Kick the Dem spin machine into overdrive. They'll deny. They'll blame Republicans. They'll blame the media for blowing the story out of proportion. They'll do anything but say "it was a bad idea, we were wrong to suggest it, we're sorry." Well, all except for the vulnerables like Mike Simpson, Terry Brown and Marc Corriveau who use the same language and phrases to express the same opinion.   They have an election to win in tight districts and can't afford to call a spade anything but a spade.

    There are so many better uses for $38 million, after all.  Like, I don't know, helping eliminate a $600+ million budget deficit?

    And while this particular budgetary skirmish plays out in the House, the Detroit News is taking a moment on their editorial page this morning to encourage Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop and his GOP brethren throughout Lansing to fight the good fight against the myriad tax hikes being tossed willy nilly by Jennifer Granholm and her foot soldiers in the House.

    The stakes, they point out, couldn't be greater.

    Already, firms in Michigan are cancelling expansion plans and putting employee hires on hold because of uncertainty about the tax climate. Companies that might have considered Michigan are looking elsewhere and those that operate here now are rightly concerned that they'll be on the hook for bailing out the state because they're not headquartered here.

    Those are the real costs of the Legislature's inaction and the Democrats' promise to increase taxes in a state that can ill afford such schemes. As we've noted, state residents' per capita personal income is below the national average; relative to the rest of the nation it's at Great Depression levels.

    This comes hot on the heels of a report by the Bureau of Economic Analysis, Census Bureau and Tax Foundation that ranks Michigan as the 36th most attractive (that's 14th worst) state when considering the overall tax burden as impacting the state's families.  (You can view the report on CNN here.)

    Think a $3 billion tax hike would make us any more attractive?  And the left wonders why no one, well, why only 14% of the state backs the governor's plan to raise taxes to pay for her big-government pet-programs.  

    And finally, in the land of Presidential politics, John McCain starts a two-day swing through Michigan today, making appearances down in Oakland County this afternoon followed by a swing over to Holland this evening and other stops in west Michigan tomorrow.

    KBH has details in the Associated Press.

    I'm going to swing by to see the Senator myself and will be back late this evening or early tomorrow with some observations and maybe a photo or two.

    < Being a friend of the Granholm administration pays... literally | Cushingberry trial under way... House budget process languishes as Approps put on hold >
    Display: Sort:
    SBT Repeal (1.00 / 1) (#1)
    by NoviDemocrat on Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 10:22:04 AM EST
    "Already, firms in Michigan are cancelling expansion plans and putting employee hires on hold because of uncertainty about the tax climate. "

    Nice try - this has been what businesses have been saying for months because of the ill-planned SBT repeal with no planned replacement for it.

    Lets not forget (5.00 / 1) (#2)
    by Nick on Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 10:35:01 AM EST
    that the Senate proposed an SBT replacement back in February.  They called it the B.E.S.T. plan and have since even retweaked it.

    The Governor and the House refuse to look at it though, and neither have proposed an alternative (though Granholm has spoken of an alternative in generalities).

    Re: SBT Repeal (5.00 / 1) (#3)
    by Jeremy Nielson on Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 10:35:11 AM EST
    Yeah, that's the same SBT Repeal that Governor Granholm was against...

    Before being for it..

    Then against it.

    Then offered her own solution, which was rejected... which made her against it again.

    Nevermind the fact that it would've been on the ballot in November, and by all accounts would've passed.  But hey, Granholm really showed her leadership on that one!

    Whitehall project on hold (5.00 / 1) (#4)
    by Spartyfan on Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 12:53:18 PM EST
    Tell Novi Dem to read the Muskegon Chronicle today about a tannery project put on hold.  Mainly because the Gov. put a hold on all grants - but the fact that Michigan's jobs are scurrying away is indisputable.

    The SBT (5.00 / 1) (#5)
    by sdogg1m on Thu Apr 12, 2007 at 12:55:32 PM EST
    Businesses in this country and in the State of Michigan DO NOT PAY taxes, so the idea of an SBT provides false fuzzies for the liberal base.

    Learn to balance the budget without the SBT and start cutting to make Michigan competitive once again.

    I have have thought of ten different ways to cut billions from the budget and will eventually write them down for critique.

    Cutting 600 million from a 43 billion dollar budget cannot be that difficult.

    • Try 2 billion by NoviDemocrat, 04/12/2007 10:43:46 PM EST (none / 0)
    NoviDemocrat (5.00 / 1) (#7)
    by sdogg1m on Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 02:10:33 AM EST
    Try again! Democrats will never understand that businesses turn around and implement the cost of taxation into their products and services.

    So tell me once again who pay the taxes? It is you NoviDemocrat thats who.

    My point (5.00 / 1) (#9)
    by sdogg1m on Fri Apr 13, 2007 at 12:32:44 PM EST
    My point is either keep taxes low or in the end you get hit with a double whammy.

    Number 1: State businesses who are taxed turn around and raise prices on good and services the increase in price could cause a reduction in business. The reduction in business COSTS jobs.

    Number 2: Those who do end up paying the higher cost for the goods and services pay less for other products which in turn causes a loss of jobs.

    Do I think that businesses shouldn't pay taxes ever? Not necessarily but the idea of single business tax for businesses to pay their FAIR SHARE is ridiculous. What makes a business run? Citizens!!! Who in the end has to pay, CITIZENS!!!

    Please NoviDemocrat, I am not trying to personally attack you but start look objectively at the matter.

    Most liberals/democrats I know absolutely hate their workplace and management but then again they don't quit their job. Why? Because they like the fact that the company pays them a good wage/benefits/etc.

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Join the RightMichigan.com Facebook Group HERE!
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!
    create account | faq | search