Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • Tags
  • RSS Feed




  • RightMichigan.com

    Twitter Feed

    Report finds Jennifer Granholm's DHS directly responsible for childrens' deaths


    By Nick, Section News
    Posted on Tue Feb 12, 2008 at 07:02:32 AM EST
    Tags: (all tags)

    As a child advocacy group prepares for it's date taking the State of Michigan to court reports and details surrounding the tragic deaths of numerous wards of the State continue to hit the newswires.  And the more we hear the uglier things look.  The preventable deaths of five children comprise the centerpiece of a study issued yesterday.  These are kids whose interests the State of Michigan were supposed to be looking after.  The Department of Human Services didn't just fail.  At times they may have been complicit.  

    The Ivory Tower reports on several of the cases in question:


    • A 2-year-old boy beaten and burned to death in a foster home that had been cited for maltreatment nine times before he was placed there.

    • A 14-year-old girl diagnosed with depression who hanged herself in foster care after the state failed to address her mental health problems.

    • A 15-month-old girl beaten to death while staying with her mother and grandparents in foster care after suffering previous abuse that resulted in a fractured skull and a burned foot.

    • A 7-week-old boy who appeared to have suffocated from a pillow on an adult bed.

    • A 3 1/2 -year-old boy who died of head injuries in the foster home of a woman found to have abused her own daughter the previous year.

    The author of the report does more than highlight the problems, too.  They've ascribed blame, stating that at times the State was directly responsible for preventable and tragic deaths.

    Now hold your horses for just one second.  I can already hear what the Governor's loyal defenders are saying.  This isn't Jennifer Granholm's fault.  This isn't the State's fault.  No.  This is what happens when we don't pay enough in taxes, when we don't budget enough for DHS and when we overburden hard working state employees.

    To which I respond, bollocks.  

    Every year the Governor manages to deliver a State of the State speech that calls for more programs and more spending.  Every year the Governor manages to submit a budget radically increasing the size of State government.  And yet every year these problems go uncorrected.

    If it was a simple matter of appropriations, and that's been the problem all along, why hasn't Jennifer Granholm made this the central issue of her term in office?  Why isn't raising that extra capitol her number one priority?  All rhetoric aside, kids are literally dying.  Doesn't get much more serious than that.  

    The problem is much deeper than any incorrectly perceived budgetary shortfall.  As we discussed last week, the first responsibility of any State agency is to uphold the law.  Granholm's Department of Human Services routinely fails to make even a single follow-up visit with the children they place, a threshold below the requirements of law.  

    Read on...

    What we have is a broken department with chronically failed leadership and when that department and that leadership are responsible for the safety and well being of some of the State's most vulnerable residents things can get really scary really fast.  According to the Detroit News:

    "What's really striking and frankly horrifying is that the report gives us a tip of an iceberg of children taken into the care of Michigan's foster care system -- five kids who died because of poor efforts to surround them with the proper services and a safety net," said Sara Bartosz, an attorney for Children's Rights, a New York-based advocacy organization that has filed a class action lawsuit against the state. "It shows a history of a management that has seen holes in a safety net but even after children have died have not fixed and mended that safety net..."

    Child abuse and neglect investigators do not yield enough evidence and "often make determinations that are not consistent with the facts," according to the report. As an example, the report points to the death of James (Earl Bradley, Jr.), which a coroner ruled a homicide and physician said likely resulted from child abuse. But the Michigan Department of Human Services investigation showed that there was not a preponderance of evidence to support child abuse, a conclusion the report called "entirely inconsistent with facts and ridiculous."

    Whatever it is we're spending on DHS, it certainly doesn't seem to be used effectively.  All we see are chronic failures that devastate families.  Sort of the Granholm legacy at this point.  

    Maybe the next time someone reports child abuse we could send in the Marines instead.  Looks like they may need a place to do some training, though the City of Grand Rapids is doing what it can to help.  The Grand Rapids Press reports on the growing scandal surrounding the mayor of Toledo, a first class creep who kicked the Marines out of his city the day of a vital training exercise because he though it was scary.  Homeless and without a critical training location the unit was forced to return home and start looking for a new place to practice their urban warfare tactics.

    "When the U.S Marines call, you answer," said (Grand Rapids Police Lt. Ralph) Mason...

    Mason, who took the call late Friday afternoon, offered the use of a vacant elementary school building used by Grand Rapids police for tactical training. But the offer came too late for the unit to act on it.

    Toledo Mayor Carty Finkbeiner ignited a firestorm of controversy in Toledo and beyond when he said he feared the Marines would frighten downtown residents and workers...

    To some Toledo residents, Finkbeiner's stand is reminiscent of the controversy he raised in 1994 when he suggested at a staff meeting that a way to resolve complaints about airport noise would be to move deaf people into the neighborhood.

    Gotta love the liberal mindset.  The state can do anything including picking up and transplanting residents based on physical handicaps but try to let the United States Military train as they've always trained and oh no, that'd be crossing the line.

    Props to the GRPD for stepping up to the plate.  It didn't work out this time but it may the next.  And while this issue is far more serious than any game, here's hoping MSU and U of M lay a serious beating on OSU next fall.  Our Marines aren't good enough for you?  That whole State's got it coming for this one.

    < Quick note on site "beautification" | Tuesday in the Sphere, February 12 >


    Share This: Digg! StumbleUpon del.icio.us reddit reddit


    Display: Sort:
    DHS Management (none / 0) (#1)
    by Shell on Tue Feb 12, 2008 at 08:54:32 AM EST
    The Children's Rights report findings are no surprise, but I'm glad the gross mismanagement within DHS is finally being reported on.  And believe me, "gross" is an understatement!  Did you know that social workers, who are mandated to receive specific training with regard to policy, are not only NOT being given time to attend training sessions, they are not FORCED by management to use the new guidelines?  

    For the heck of it, I looked up the name of one director on the Lansing State Journal's salary database.  She makes $97,000 a year -- before benefits -- to demonstrate incompetence, micromanaging and wasteful spending of taxpayer dollars.  It's beyond gross, it's downright nauseating.

    Shell,
    The Conservatrarian

    We could come up with nasty adjectives all day (none / 0) (#2)
    by Nick on Tue Feb 12, 2008 at 11:50:17 AM EST
    to describe this sort of abject failure.  (Oh, look.  I did it again.  Abject.  That's a good one.)

    Ask the Good Senator Bishop (none / 0) (#3)
    by NoviDemocrat on Wed Feb 13, 2008 at 12:56:01 AM EST
    "If it was a simple matter of appropriations, and that's been the problem all along, why hasn't Jennifer Granholm made this the central issue of her term in office? "

    Who are you kidding? Every budget session, the Republicons are waving their budget axes at every aspect of state government that doesn't enrich their corporate interests, targeting departments like DHS for cuts. Name one Republicon who's stepped up to advocate for DHS? Can you name one?

    I find it funny..... (none / 0) (#6)
    by nickburns480 on Wed Feb 13, 2008 at 02:37:16 PM EST
    The liberal freep reported the story.  So not only is Granholm killing jobs, she's killing children!  Think about the children!  Please!!!!  Think about the children!

    Ed, feel free to repost minus the (none / 0) (#8)
    by Nick on Sat Feb 16, 2008 at 12:30:01 PM EST
    name calling.  I know.  I know, man.  Believe me, I know.  But you're right on the issue.  Devestate him that way.  I know you can. :)

    A $400 MILLION Dollar Budget Hole? (none / 0) (#9)
    by Shell on Sun Feb 17, 2008 at 02:19:52 PM EST
    This won't come as any surprise but according to a new AP story this morning, if Children's Rights wins the lawsuit against DHS (scheduled for trial in June), it could blast a $400 million dollar hole in the budget.

    The article is posted here:  http://www.mlive.com/newsflash/michigan/index.ssf?/base/news-51/1203255844229950.xml&storylist=n ewsmichigan&thispage=1

    The state is trying to improve, hiring nearly 200 more foster care workers this budget year and boosting rates paid to private agencies that care for abused, neglected or delinquent children. The next budget proposed by Gov. Jennifer Granholm would continue funding the extra workers and higher payments.

    Boosting private agency rates??  The lobbyists for private agencies push congressmen to increase their spending, but there's no oversight.  Most of the money goes into the director's pockets and front line workers are paid pittance, and they've got a turnover rate worse than the state.  Foster care workers must have at least a bachelor's degree but there's at least two years of on-the-job training for them to be proficient.  Many don't last that long at $22,000 a year salaries.  Private agencies are also notorious for NOT following state and federal policy guidelines, providing paperwork and copying last month's case notes and resubmitting them as new.

    Kresnak said nobody wants the state under a federal consent decree and estimated Michigan could avoid that by spending an extra $130 million to $150 million on child welfare in the fiscal year that starts Oct. 1. A loss at trial may "blow a $400 million hole in the state budget," he said. "We've got to be a little flexible."

    Where will THIS money come from?  I'm not sure if federal oversight would automatically strip DHS of the money it receives or not, so this could go even higher.

    The generally accepted standard caseload is between 12 and 15 per worker for foster care. But many workers carry more than 30 cases.

    My family member in DHS says the 12-15 caseload standard is incorrect and doesn't know where these numbers come from.  He does, however, know of caseloads as high 45.  

    This article does a good job at articulating the basic failures of the foster care system, but things are only going to get worse and it has little to do with money.  The stereotypical "foster child" of decades ago -- a poor, deprived but basically good child in need of a family -- are long gone.  Many are extremely emotionally disturbed, need special mental health care (which requires a LOT of office visits and management), and there's a chronic shortage of foster care parents.  As word gets around about RAD, FAS and how hard to control these kids are (hence the numerous, short-term placements), the fewer families will sign up.  It's a Catch-22 and it's going to get even more ugly.

    Shell,
    The Conservatrarian

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Join the RightMichigan.com Facebook Group HERE!
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!
    create account | faq | search