Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • Tags
  • RSS Feed




  • RightMichigan.com

    Twitter Feed

    Part-time campaign wrong for Michigan


    By dennislennox, Section News
    Posted on Wed Jun 04, 2008 at 03:21:31 PM EST
    Tags: (all tags)

    The rhetoric advancing the idea of a constitutional amendment to make the state Legislature part-time fails to mention that such a move would be a horrible blow to Average Joes across Michigan.

    Instead of spending thousands of dollars on a campaign to amend the Michigan Constitution of 1963, backers should be lobbying legislators -- who could introduce a simple motion tomorrow morning to adjourn from session and effectively go part-time without all the fuss of a ballot question.

    Read on ...

    But doing so would require telling the truth, which is something the moneyed special interests -- who are pushing a part-time amendment -- don't want to do.

    In reality, this effort would fundamentally change Michigan government for the worse by weakening the people's voice in Lansing and greatly empowering bureaucrats, lobbyists and the governor.

    Senators and representatives in states with a part-time mandate seldom have the experience they need to be an effective voice for the people.

    In fact, many of these legislatures only meet once every other year for a very limited period of 30 or 60 days. Instead of serving as a true check-and-balance on the executive and judicial branches of government, they end up functioning with decisions made in advance -- away from the scrutiny of the public -- by unelected bureaucrats.

    While critics of the Michigan Legislature point to the last year's budget debacle, it's certain the crisis would have been considerably worse if those legislators had been part-time.

    Additionally, the $1.4 billion tax increase on families and businesses would have been substantially higher had the governor got what she wanted, which usually happens in states where the people's voice is part-time and controlled by special interests.

    Many will also talk about the salary of Michigan's legislators.

    It's true they get paid a lot more than counterparts in many states, however, they also do considerably more work and are also considerably more independent than others.

    Michigan is larger -- both geographically and by population -- than most states with part-time legislatures. You can actually drive from Detroit to Washington, D.C., quicker than driving to many locations in the western Upper Peninsula.

    Yet despite our state's size, most of our legislators make an effort to commute back and forth between their districts and Lansing. They attend local meetings, go to festivals, hold office hours and go out of their way to listen and learn from their constituents.

    Having a higher salary also ensures independence from the influences of special interests. It's also worth pointing out that most corruption and bribery charges involving politicians are found in states with part-time legislators, who in some cases receive a salary of $10 a day.

    Paying Michigan's legislators the compensation they deserve also allows Average Joes to run for office, and reducing their pay to part-time levels would mean only retirees, trial lawyers, union bosses and those with connections to big-money special interests could serve. I doubt few would want this as the composition of Lansing.

    Most importantly, the part-time initiatives out there would secretly do away with term limits, which were overwhelmingly approved by Michigan voters in 1992.

    I agree that term limits have negatively impacted state government, but this is because the limitations are too short.

    Instead of doing away with them completely, proponents of going part-time should refocus their efforts to extend the current limitations on service -- allowing legislators to gain the experience they need to be effective voices for the people.

    The truth is there is little truth in the arguments of those who want the state Legislature to be reduced to part-time status, which is why their effort likely won't make the ballot in November.

    < Meet Marietta Robinson | GOP health care card >


    Share This: Digg! StumbleUpon del.icio.us reddit reddit


    Display: Sort:
    Eliminating the Legislative Branch (none / 0) (#2)
    by Brady on Wed Jun 04, 2008 at 08:41:02 PM EST
    A part-time Legislature is another bad idea just like term limits for the very reasons Dennis mentions.  Term limits and the elimination of JCAR severely weakened the oversight power of the Legislature.  A part-time Legislature would kill oversight all together.  Even the concept of legislating would essentially evaporate as almost all new laws would be made by bureaucrats through the rules process.  That certainly won't be good for supporters of limited government.

    A Stand for the Status Quo? (none / 0) (#3)
    by Beerme on Mon Jul 14, 2008 at 06:38:09 PM EST
    I see this article certainly makes the Michigan legislature look good by comparison to those other states who have a part-time, lower paid congress but I'm not sure I can agree with the premise that we're getting what we're paying for.

    I take exception to several statements in this article. As Michigan's status is just about last of fifty, we can't possibly be better off than other states who may have a part-time legislature. As the legislators we have are largely doing very little good but a whole lot of bad (and doing the unnecessary is bad, too), we can't be happier with our lot than other states. Finally, when we get the quality of congressperson we have in Michigan (mostly), we MUST be paying them too much!

    Sorry, but part-time is a good idea. Professional, full-time politicians think they need to be doing something all the time-because they're getting paid, you know. Most of the time, I'd rather they were sitting at home watching a ballgame. It would be cheaper and preserve more of my freedoms if they did!

    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Join the RightMichigan.com Facebook Group HERE!
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!

    Related Links

    + Also by dennislennox
    create account | faq | search