Political News and Commentary with the Right Perspective. NAVIGATION
  • Front Page
  • News
  • Multimedia
  • Tags
  • RSS Feed




  • RightMichigan.com

    Twitter Feed

    McCain: Forgoing native MI directors in favor of messaging brilliance?


    By Nick, Section News
    Posted on Wed Jul 16, 2008 at 09:28:48 AM EST
    Tags: (all tags)

    It seems impossible to open a newspaper this month without reading about the inside-baseball goings on inside each of the Presidential campaigns in Michigan.  We're being bombarded with stories touting the unprecedented size of the Barackstar's paid Michigan effort (instructively, it is twice the size of John Kerry's in 2004, a year Michigan was considered "in play"... what then does that say about Democrats' assessment of Republican prospects to retake the Great Lakes State in 2008?).  We're reading every day about "unforced errors" compelling major staff shakeups in the Republican camp and the announcement and arrival of new senior staff members in both the local Obama and McCain campaigns.  

    One couldn't pay the Associated Press enough to actually dig past the surface into either candidate's issue positions (and gnawing personal inconsistencies) but the MSM is more than happy to tell you who is working at what office where because, apparently, the name "Amy Chapman" is supposed to matter to us.  Ms. Chapman is the Obama campaign's Michigan Director, by the way.  See?  Don't you feel better informed and more prepared to provide for your family today?  

    If you've followed all of the staffing announcements, and let's be honest, who HASN'T, there is one noticeable trend.  Neither state campaign is being fronted by a Michigan native.  Chapman is an Oregon girl and the McCain campaign's Michigan director is Jennifer Hallowell, the former executive director for the Indiana Republican Party.  

    Of course, the Great Lakes State was always able to boast that the Arizona Senator's national efforts included Michigan native and political consultant John Yob.  The son of long-time National Committeeman Chuck Yob, John was intimately involved for years with the old straight-talk express and gave the state a little shot of parochial pride.  It isn't clear what condition that pride should be in today.  Since beginning a major shakeup of national staff, consultants and advisors just before the July 4th holiday I'm told no one has heard a peep from Yob and the McCain national HQ has yet to formally address his role with the campaign (or lack of a role, whichever may be the case).

    If Yob is no longer with the Republican Presidential effort Michigan will suddenly find herself in an interesting position... a widely acknowledged battleground state at the center of the electoral storm but without a major staff-level Michigan voice on either side of contest.  

    Bad news, right?  Maybe not.  

    Read on...

    Just typing those words seems odd but there's a chance it could be true.  It is impossible to be fond of the idea that so few open political jobs in Michigan go to folks who pay taxes here but set that issue aside for a moment.  Look at the action the last two weeks.  

    The Obama campaign, since bringing in outsiders, has finally begun a painfully-long-overdue discussion with Michigan voters, though it seems now entirely of the pay-to-play, cynical, politics-as-usual variety.  With several hundred (you read that right) paid staffers expected on the streets in forty-some-odd field offices the Democratic campaign looks ready and willing to drown the state in millions of those integrity-defying, non-public-financing campaign dollars.  Did it take an Oregon native to force the Senator to open that ethically challenged piggy bank in Michigan?

    The change is even more profound when you look at the McCain campaign.  The Senator has never been the stranger that Obama was these last two years.  While the Clown Prince of Change (TM and Patent Pending) ignored Michigan for a full year, refusing to step foot in-state, McCain was a regular guest.  He continues to single the State out for destination campaigning, wrapping up a series of visits and a town hall meeting just last week while preparing another set for this Friday.  But standing behind a podium and giving a double-barreled thumbs up to the thumb will only get you so far if your message is off target.

    In early May, with that familiar local voice well represented in his national campaign, McCain made headlines by appearing in Southeast Michigan, ground zero for the nation's economic difficulties and the home of an auto industry going through painful, long-term contraction.  He had a chance to discuss the economy and more importantly, to speak directly to hurting people about the issues dominating their lives.  Instead he talked about child pornography.  

    The messaging gaffe led MSM'er Susan Demas to aptly observe that "on the list of (the) top 1,000 issues for Michiganders, kiddie porn ranks about 1,263,000."  Talk about "unforced errors."

    Fast forward to July 2nd and the subsequent staffing announcements out of the "Maverick's" Washington, D.C. operation.  We may not yet know how deep and far-reaching the Michigan related national level staffing changes are but the difference in local execution has been profound.  With local "Victory Centers" opening across the state Senator McCain returned to Southeast Michigan last week to do nothing less than unveil his national economic plan, a plan that was widely praised by local small business owners and job providers and was immediately endorsed by well over three-hundred of the nation's leading economists.  This Friday's scheduled visit again plays to the candidate's strengths, setting him up with a town hall meeting while surrogates like the locally popular Mitt Romney appropriately handle the "light work" of formally opening staff offices.

    Gone too are the goofy backdrops and the faux pomp and circumstance of sloppily staged speeches on obscure topics, replaced by sit-down meetings with auto workers and one-on-one conversations at Coney Island restaurants, talking over chili dogs with real Michigan people literally where they work and live.  In two weeks time McCain's Michigan effort has transformed from Exhibit A of what was wrong with a floundering national campaign into the perfect example of how to use a candidate's time to conduct a well refined, laser-targeted messaging war.

    To all of the out-of-staters heading our way for the first time in years, welcome.  Bring your staff level friends with you!  Because if it comes down to a choice between parochial pride and an effective, focused campaign engaging Michigan voters on Michigan issues seeking solutions to Michigan problems, well, there's really no choice at all.

    < Meadows 'borrowing' student's proposal to change term limits | An Introduction to the First >


    Share This: Digg! StumbleUpon del.icio.us reddit reddit


    Display: Sort:
    between one and the other (none / 0) (#1)
    by Chris Arndt on Thu Jul 17, 2008 at 04:16:16 PM EST
    I bet we get neither.
    http://apologiesdemanded.blogspot.com
    Display: Sort:

    Login

    Make a new account

    Username:
    Password:
    Join the RightMichigan.com Facebook Group HERE!
    Tweet along with RightMichigan by
    following us on Twitter HERE!
    create account | faq | search